The U.S. steel industry is at risk of falling behind global competitors in adopting advanced technologies, due to fluctuations in federal support and constraints on electricity supply. To secure the industry’s future, federal policymakers must ensure a stable, affordable supply of electricity and support development and demonstration of advanced production technologies and infrastructure to improve efficiency and circularity.

Why it matters: Steel is a foundational industry for U.S. economic and national security, essential for everything from domestic manufacturing to critical infrastructure. While efficient, scrap-based Electric Arc Furnace (EAF) production in particular underpins the industry’s competitive edge today, an affordable electricity supply is becoming a constraint. At the same time, producers must modernize primary steel production to compete globally in the coming decades.

Some industry leaders surveyed by Carnegie Mellon University expect a slower pace of technology deployment compared to last year, primarily due to financial hurdles, policy shifts, and insufficient electricity supply. Policy action is crucial to restore momentum and protect U.S. manufacturing leadership.

Action: CMU convened experts representing more than 20% of global steel production for its 2025 Accelerating Green Steel Workshop (AGSW). Experts representing both integrated and EAF production shared their experiences and goals and provided feedback on CMU research.

Findings: Key findings from the workshop reinforce the need for U.S. policy to support modernization of iron and steel production:

  • Electricity access and affordability is a bottleneck: The access and affordability of electricity emerged as a major concern. Competition from high-demand sectors like data centers further increases the urgency of expanding grid capacity and generation to power new, electrified industrial processes.
  • Government financial support is needed: While tariffs target unfair competition, government financial support is needed to enhance competitiveness globally. The high capital and operational costs of new technology are the most significant limiting factors for modernization today.
  • Support first-of-a-kind deployments: Strong early-stage support — such as capital incentives and guaranteed purchase agreements that create incentives to increase the efficiency of existing processes and deploy technologies like natural gas-based and hydrogen-based Direct Reduced Iron (DRI) and electrolytic ironmaking will help de-risk and accelerate adoption.

Go deeper: AGSW co-chairs Valerie Karplus, associate director of the Scott Institute for Energy Innovation, and Chris Pistorius, co-director of CMU’s Center for Iron and Steelmaking Research, can discuss these findings and their broader expertise in advanced iron and steel technologies and industrial competitiveness.

Meet the faculty experts